Capizzi NYC Review: Amazing Pizza Worth Every Bite

[rating:4]

Summary of Capizzi Review NYC – In terms of the food, the pizza, this place is phenomenal and highly recommended! They even earn an Editor’s Choice award for great pizza! By the way, I’m going to change that award picture soon. LOL. Using my mug was not a smart idea. Hahah.

I was invited to try out Capizzi by the owner, Joe Calcagno. We were trying to set up a time for me to stop by when I could meet and greet him, get to talk to some of his staff members, and try out his pizza. Joe found me online as one of the many pizza lovers in NYC, so he reached out and extended this generous offer.

The day that we agreed upon arrived, but as is often the case with life, things changed. I was scheduled to hit the pizza shop at 3:30pm; we chose that time because it’s not as busy, and I could actually talk and sample the food calmly with no rush or pressure. Unfortunately, my teammate at work called out that day, so I had to cover both the early and late shifts. This meant that I could not leave the office until at least 6pm.

I mentioned this hiccup to Joe and offered to reschedule. He seemed pretty disappointed, so being the eager reviewer that I am, I asked if I could come over later. He stated that he couldn’t make it later, but that I could still come by, and his chef and staff would be aware and expecting me.

This is where the story gets a little unusual. When I arrived at the restaurant, it was jam-packed! This is great for a restaurant, less ideal for a guy showing up to review the place. LOL. There was no place for me to sit, and I think I caught them a bit off guard when I showed up and introduced myself. I’m not sure I was fully expected. However, anyone who knows me knows I’m a trooper, and I make the best out of most situations I find myself in.

I considered leaving and coming back another day. However, since I was already there and don’t often get to this area, I told Chef Simon that I didn’t mind standing by the kitchen and eating the pizza. He asked if I was sure, and I said not to worry about it. Looking back, I do regret this decision. In terms of comfort and really enjoying the meal, I was rather uncomfortable. The spot where I stood was busy with bathroom and kitchen traffic, so I was constantly stepping aside to get out of the way. I did enjoy chatting with Chef Simon and the other crew members; they were a great group, and I got to watch the chef make the pizza while talking about the equipment and ingredients. But as far as physical comfort, it was not ideal. Lesson learned.

Chef Simon tossing some dough in the air!
Chef Simon tossing some dough in the air!

When I was almost done with my food, I was introduced to a head waiter there, a gentleman who boxes professionally. We also chatted for a while; he offered me a seat, but at that point, I was nearly finished and didn’t want to be a bother. These guys had extended me an invitation, and I felt it wouldn’t be right to take up a seat during prime time when a paying customer could use it. That said, the timing is something I regret. I should have insisted on going during a lower-traffic time so I could eat comfortably without imposing on the business. Lesson learned, I’ll keep this in mind next time.

Let’s get to the actual Capizzi Review NYC!

EDITOR'S FAV!
EDITOR’S FAV!

So, great story, but how about getting to the food already? Yes, you’re right, let’s get to the food! I’m a simple man; I take great pleasure in the simple things in life. So I went with a basic margherita personal pie. This consisted solely of the dough, sauce, and cheese. Let me tell you, as far as pizza goes, this place was phenomenal! The last time I had pizza this good was from our friends at the Neapolitan Express food truck! What stood out the most for me was the sauce. As I think back, my mind’s eye keeps going to that sauce!

The dough was just the right level of soft and crunchy. When I bit into it, the textures were perfect. Everything was balanced just right. Chef Simon said the mozzarella was fresh, and you could tell by looking at the pie. This was not an oily or greasy pizza cheese. Sometimes when you get a slice, there’s so much oil on the cheese it’s overwhelming. I love pizza, but due to health reasons, I can’t have it often, especially not the greasy 99-cent slices. If I did, I’d get a migraine within half an hour, so I’m selective about when and where I eat my pizza.

Next, the sauce, my favorite component of this pie. It was a perfect combination of sweet and salty. I didn’t get a chance to ask where the tomatoes come from, but the sauce was excellent! Even writing this now, I’m craving some of that pizza. I did want to try other styles, but since I was uncomfortable standing, I didn’t want to linger.

I tried one of their lemonade drinks, which was also pretty good. Not too sweet, not too sour. It was Goldilocks-level lemonade: just right! Haha. Finally, I was given a dessert, a panna cotta, for my wife. I brought it home for her. She enjoyed it over the next two days. Unfortunately, I didn’t go straight home, so the panna cotta’s appearance changed from a neat dish to a melted mess. Lol. However, this didn’t affect the flavor; my wife described it as very creamy and Goldilocks “just right” in taste.

Overall, the experience was enjoyable. I didn’t care much for constantly having to move out of the way, but aside from that, I had a great time and the pizza was phenomenal! There’s nothing like good pizza made with high-quality ingredients.

This reminds me of when I was a kid. I used to make fun of what I called “gourmet pizza.” Back then, I thought $1.25 corner slices were all I needed! I used to frown on places like this, thinking of them as upscale pizza spots. Today, I really appreciate how good this pizza is, and mind you, I’m not wealthy! It was just so good! Anyway, if you’re in the area or want to try great pizza, check out Capizzi. The pizza is absolutely wonderful. I do recommend getting a seat, though. Hahaha. Life is great!

Capizzi on Urbanspoon

Angel Rodriguez
Angel Rodriguez

Just a life long New Yorker sharing the journey through my lens.

Articles: 3429

2 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *